Sunday, May 3, 2009

Poverty with a view, redux.

It's been interesting to watch everyone around me go through an economic relapse -- which is something I've been through many times before.

I never believed it at the time, but having my sales drop in half overnight, from the burst bubbles of pogs, beanie babies, sports cards, comics, Pokemon, etc. etc. was pretty good training for what's happening now.

But I have always felt that, except for the extraordinary last five years of boom, that the Bend economy almost always gave marginal returns to investment. (Of time, energy, and money.)

I believe that the same investment in a larger metro area would bring greater returns almost every time.

There are a few exceptions, but mostly, we natives came up with a phrase to explain it, to excuse it, to rationalize why we stayed.

"Poverty with a View."

I still think that way. I think Bend is a great place to live. Personally, I like almost everything about it, except the asinine growth (McMansions on small lots/Hummers/ and seeming enough retail to satisfy a town twice our size) over the last five years.

And frankly, I can mostly ignore that.

We've got good bones. We may have added a few layers of fat, but underneath, we're still beautiful.

I'm sorry that so many have lost faith in Bend. Some are leaving in disillusionment (and necessity, of course.) Others are staying, stuck in their jobs, but complaining.

But, I think we're just reverting to the Old Bend. The Bend that I lived in most of my life, the Bend that existed in the first 20 years of my business.

For the first ten years, it was a struggle to keep a business alive in downtown Bend, and then, just as normally we might have started to thrive, we had huge amounts of retail come to town over the next ten years. Look around you, almost all the retail centers and big boxes came to Bend in the '90's.

Only in the 00's did we start to outperform the historical norm.

And as I've said many times before, I think this was mostly illusion. A bubble waiting to pop.

I believe the quicker we adjust to the Poverty with a View outlook, the quicker we're on our way to dealing with this. I'm not advocating giving up, but just being realistic in expectations.

I think not only are we not yet near the bottom, but we still have growth going on that is based almost solely on the illusion of the boom years.

Which will only extend the length of the painful adjustment.

11 comments:

H. Bruce Miller said...

"I think we're just reverting to the Old Bend. The Bend that I lived in most of my life, the Bend that existed in the first 20 years of my business."

If only that were true I'd be motivated to stay here. Unfortunately the Old Bend is gone forever. We can't unbuild all the crappy sprawling development that's been allowed to happen over the past 20 years. It will be around for a long, long time. And vacant McMansions and shopping centers are even uglier than occupied ones.

No, we're not going to be the Old Bend again. More like the New Akron.

H. Bruce Miller said...

"I believe the quicker we adjust to the Poverty with a View outlook ..."

Trouble is the view isn't there anymore. They built a shopping center in front of it.

So we've got Poverty with ... Poverty.

Barney Lerten said...

I do like the fact that Duncan isn't all cheery-Pollyana about the Recovery Under Way, or all "we're hostages from hell and all we can do is cry for mercy" (Firesign Theater) like a certain Bubble blogger.
Extremes are interesting, but the truth usually lies in the muddle of the middle.

Duncan McGeary said...

Reality of downturns are just more slow, and murky, and banal.

Duncan McGeary said...

At the same time, there is a terrified knot in your stomach.

Anonymous said...

Hey Barney, what recovery under way?

Bewert said...

Re: ...but the truth usually lies in the muddle of the middle.

###

If only we were in the middle, BD.

You know the RE appreciation and current UE stats.

IHateToBurstYourBubble said...

I do like the fact that Duncan isn't all cheery-Pollyana about the Recovery Under Way, or all "we're hostages from hell and all we can do is cry for mercy" (Firesign Theater) like a certain Bubble blogger.

Who is it! Let's get the bastard! He's threatening this broad-based, but still amorphous and hope-based RECOVERY!

Yesirree, Cessna would stay, Yarrow would sell, and Bend Media could go back to telling the truth, instead LYING THEIR ASSES OFF EVERY SINGLE DAY.

If we could get rid of these Negative Nelly's, we'd get back to the Bubble Years in no time!

Anonymous said...

"I do like the fact that Duncan [is] in the muddle of the middle."

I also like Duncan's approach, but just because he's the average of two extremes doesn't make him right. On the major points the local "extreme" bubble blog has a damn impressive track record.

"Respectable" media tends to play it safe and aim for the "muddle of the middle". If a prominent person says that the earth is flat, the headline is "opinions on the shape of the earth differ". A good journalist will let you know what the right answer is somewhere in the article, but the headline is still there.

The truth can be quite different than the average of two extremes (a black swan).

In this case, however, hopefully it is closer to the average than at the most dire predictions.

H. Bruce Miller said...

"The truth can be quite different than the average of two extremes (a black swan)."

Barney would insist the swan was a shade of gray. Very, very dark gray.

Good post, and good point. Sometimes one opinion IS wrong and the opposite opinion IS right.

Bend Economy Man said...

Not to pile on Barney's "truth in the middle" statement, but I agree with the view that Bend's more likely to continue to follow the path of extremes.

Over the last few years, Bend MSA has been ranked:

* at the top in median home price appreciation
* at the top in "overpriced" residential real estate
* near the top in year-over-year population growth

...and then...* near the top in absolute unemployment
* at the top in year-over-year increase in unemployment
* near the top in median home price depreciation

Bend's growth was extreme so its decline is also going to be extreme. I don't expect local mainstream media to report on this until it's actually happened, though.

As in the case with the RE bubble, there are certain things that you just can't expect Bend mainstream media (The Bulletin and KTVZ) to report. And one of them is any story that suggests that the smartest thing to do is to pack up and leave town because things aren't going to get any better for a long time. I guess there's journalistic integrity, and then there's shooting yourself in the foot.

On the other hand, local media will publish/broadcast stories consisting 100% of POSITIVE fluff predictions that suggest that readers/viewers have made a shrewd choice in moving to/staying in Bend. My favorite is this one: http://bendbulletin.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060410/BIZ0102/604100316. Lot of statements in there that are hilarious in hindsight.