Saturday, January 1, 2011

What is it about Bend...?

What is it about Bend that causes newcomers to overextend?

I'm sure it happens everywhere, but it seem particularly acute in Bend. People come here and seem to completely misjudge the level of business they can do here. Always on the high side. Almost always.

I think sometimes that people see Bend as a nascent Eugene, say -- or some Rockie mountains tourist town, or California coast town. Someplace like that.

Having lived in Bend my whole life, I see us as more as an overgrown Prineville. Burns with a few mountains nearby. Having watched ALL businesses struggle just to survive throughout most of the 80's, it was eye-popping to see people pouring into town and seeming to transform it overnight.

And yet, what fundamentally had changed? Tourism got bigger? Retirement got bigger?

Of course, we know the bubble inflated the construction and real estate industries. And it followed that retail and services would expand to meet the perceived need. But it was more than that. It seemed as though enough people wanted a vibrant restaurant and theater and music and sports scene, and by-golly that what they got.

But...the financial underpinnings still seem pretty weak to me. The dollar producing industries seem lacking. Tourism and retirement is a minimum wage job producing industry.

I'm not saying you can't succeed in Bend, only that it's tougher than it looks. Something about the isolation, the demographics, the lack of an interstate, the de facto lack of a four year university, lack of major industry, dependence on tourism and retirement, etc. etc.

These factors somehow belie the 'metro' status of Bend, the overall population, which would seem sufficient for all kinds of enterprises but lack the cohesive support of outlying or connecting populations, in my opinion.

Part of the problem is the idea of coming to Bend to prosper, to get rich. I think if you are smart, you come to Bend to 'get by' , to survive, and eventually -- if you are lucky and work hard -- prosper. But if you want to get rich quick? Bend probably isn't the place.

Anyone who lived here in the 80's instinctively knows this. I believe there are opportunities which longtimers understand come along every few decades or so to really make lots of money on the enthusiasm and innocence of newcomers -- but the really smart oldtimers know it won't last. Make hay.

I also think that when Bend became an official metro area (we were metro at 50K + 50K whereas we weren't metro at 49K + 49K) the chainstores piled in, because --- that's what chainstores do. It's in their ponzi nature to expand wherever and whenever possible.

I suspect some of them, after a couple of years, looked at their sales figures and went -- "Wow. Wasn't this supposed to be a metro area?"

Ironically, I think the very excess of growth in this town may actually tide us over until there is enough financial underpinnings to support them. I suspect a whole lot of wealth is being drained away, but as long as these newcomers can hold it together, they may get by.

And the next time there is a boom, they'll probably be like me, and be a little cautious and suspicious but try to make hay while the grass is growing.

Sorry to start the year so bracingly, but that's how I've been thinking about the end of the year.

Happy 1/1/11!

11 comments:

H. Bruce Miller said...

"I'm not saying you can't succeed in Bend, only that it's tougher than it looks. Something about the isolation, the demographics, the lack of an interstate, the de facto lack of a four year university, lack of major industry, dependence on tourism and retirement, etc. etc."

There's an old saying -- I'm sure you're heard it -- that the best way to make a small fortune in Bend is to start with a big one.

Bend isn't a major metro area and never will be. If it didn't happen to have a ski mountain nearby, it would be just another decrepit, played-out Oregon logging town.

Happy New Year.

Linda McGeary said...

Happy New Year! You're first of the year. Good!

Duncan McGeary said...

So, Bruce, when are you going to start a Blackdog blog? (Other than about weather...)

You can totally control comments -- or even dispense with them altogether....

Anonymous said...

So, Bruce, when are you going to start a Blackdog blog?


We all know that he already has!

H. Bruce Miller said...

I don't think I have anything to say that somebody else isn't saying already. I intend to just sit back and kibbitz from the sidelines.

Anonymous said...

dunc why not block all comments? I think you now spend too much time on censorship, something you didn't do in the past. love from buster now in singapore for new year holidays, ...
Let's be honest while my sites may have been nauseous, I think blackdog tends to lean a little too much towards the DEMO-DRIBBLE like yourself. Certainly I'm the first to admit that Rpugs eat shit. But you and HBM continue to defend the fucking OREO, boggles the mind. Bend is fucked, and I agree with HBM, had there not be bacherlor-butt nearby, bend would be burns. Yes, the sidelines is now good, in 2007 BEM said that all that could be said had been said, and certainly we spent 3 years making fun of the shit, ... but now its going to be another 6+ years cleaning up the shit. That's when most good folk disappear when the party is over. Bend Over.

Anonymous said...

I really think the3 following says it all about 'what is bend'.
*

Labor Day; 2009 (The Story of Bend, Oregon)

When BBC/America correspondent Adam Brookes decided to do a piece on America's economy from an 'everyman' perspective, he chose the town of Bend, from my home state of Oregon.

That those who lived in this manner simply cannot cope is an understatement. An average of four suicides per week in Bend is mute testimony to the failure of the American economy; a bankruptcy-write-large of the 'American dream'. It's possible to build a life when things are stable - but today, all bets are off.

Unknown said...

Hi Duncan,
Interesting post. I think you're right on about most of this stuff. Definitely 'anyone who was here in the '80's' is cautious. I am curious to see what happens in Bend over the next few years. I'm not as old and oldtimer as you are, but 37 years is definitely long enough to see patterns. Enjoying your blog.

Duncan McGeary said...

Buster,

2 or 3 of the deleted posts consisted of only personal attacks toward me, with no other content.

Don't see much point in that.

Anonymous said...

An average of four suicides per week in Bend is mute testimony to the failure of the American economy;

wow. Why isn't the media in this town talking about this startling stat.

Anonymous said...

Personal attacks? From an anonymous poster? What happened to the dunc of old? The man who never censored, and could face any comment, perhaps now in this late stage of the 'death of bend' dunc can no longer tolerate truth?

Why is it that all our public like bp,hp,and dp are hard core dems, and all those that hate all government are private?

It's the fear of our government that makes us anonymous dunc. Funny that those who status quo support their gubmint like Krugman or Dunc are all Dem's.
Modern OREO-OBMAM fasicism seems to not create fear within its own ranks.